Thyroid Science
A journal dedicated to truth in thyroid science and thyroid clinical practice


ABOUT US
| Home | Staff | Editorials & Latest Updates | Search Engine |
SUBMISSIONS | Authors' Guidelines | How to submit | Letters |
SECTIONS | Criticism | Clinical Cases | Debate | Clinical & Lab Studies | Hypotheses | Letters | Reviews | 

Thyroid Science 4(3):CLS1-11, 2009

Comparison of Cynomel and
Hypo Support Formula:
Their Physiological Effects


(Full Text Free in pdf format)

Dr. John C. Lowe*

*Director of Research: Fibromyalgia Research Foundation

Contact: Dr. John C. Lowe
drlowe@FibromyalgiaResearch.orgdrlowe@drlowe.com
www.FibromyalgiaResearch.org, www.drlowe.com

Apology

This abstract introduces a study report about a dietary desiccated thyroid product called "HSF." I have written a short editorial apology about two points in the report: (1) a possible error in the report concerning HSF being "organic," and (2) a  claim about HSF that in my opinion is false, that is, that it is "thyroxine-free." Some retailers are currently using the report to promote sales of HSF. Because of that, we have corrected the possible error in this reports. Editorial apology.

ABSTRACT. This study compared the clinical effectiveness of a dietary desiccated thyroid product (Hypo Support Formula or HSF), to that of a synthetic T3 product (Cynomel). Methods: A single-subject two-phase repeated-measures study design was used. Comparisons were made between two study phases: the Cynomel phase followed by the HSF phase. Clinical evaluations included four basal measures: metabolic rate (BMR), heart rate (BHR), axillary temperature (BAT), and blood pressure (BBP). Other measures were body composition, mean hypothyroid symptoms intensity, Zungís depression scale, and pain distribution. Study subjects were a female stable on 87.5 mcg of Cynomel for two years, and a male stable on 150 mcg of Cytomel or Cynomel for 24 years. In the Cynomel phase, the female remained on Cynomel through 10 evaluations on different days; the male subject remained on Cynomel through 12 evaluations. After the transition from Cynomel to HSF, she then had 10 more evaluations; the male subject had 12 more evaluations. Results: The femaleís temperature was the same in both phases. In the HSF phase, her heart rate was significantly lower and her basal metabolic rate significantly higher. A noteworthy improvement for her in the HSF phase was virtual elimination of lifelong, severe hyperhidrosis. This has persisted now for 3.5 months. The male subjectís BMR and BAT were not different in the two phases. However, during the HSF phase, he had a significantly lower heart rate, diastolic blood pressure, pain distribution, pain intensity, and mean intensity of hypothyroid symptoms. Conclusions: Both HSF and Cynomel were effective, but HSF provided additional improvements.


Keywords. Basal metabolic rate ● Basal temperature ● Cynomel ● Cytomel ● Desiccated thyroid ● Hypo Support Formula ● RLC Labs ● Triiodothyronine

 

Lowe, J.C.: Comparison of Cynomel and Hypo Support Formula:
Their physiological effects. Thyroid Science, 4(3):CLS1-11, 2009.

(Full Text Free in pdf format)

Email:   Subscribe free to Thyroid Science

© 2009 Thyroid Science