Thyroid Science
An online journal dedicated to truth in thyroid science and clinical practice

ABOUT US | Home | Journal Staff | Editorials & Latest Updates |
SUBMISSIONS | Authors' Guidelines | How to submit | Letters |
SECTIONS | Criticism | Clinical Cases | Debate | Clinical & Lab Studies | Hypotheses | Letters | Reviews |

Thyroid Science 4(10):CR1-8, 2009


Comparative Effects of
Cynomel and
Hypo Support Formula


Full Text Free
in pdf format

Dr. John C. Lowe

Director of Research: Fibromyalgia Research Foundation

Correspondence: Dr. John C. Lowe:
drlowe@FibromyalgiaResearch.org, drlowe@drlowe.com
drlowe@FibromyalgiaResearch.org, drlowe@drlowe.com
603-391-6061

Apology

This abstract introduces a study report about a dietary desiccated thyroid product called "HSF." I have written a short editorial apology about two points in the report: (1) a possible error in the report concerning HSF being "organic," and (2) a  claim about HSF that in my opinion is false, that is, that it is "thyroxine-free." Some retailers are currently using the report to promote sales of HSF. Because of that, we have corrected the possible error in this reports. Editorial apology.


Abstract. In a previous study, two subjects on stable dosages of the synthetic T3 product Cynomel found dosages of an dietary desiccated thyroid product (Hypo Support Formula or HSF) that maintained or improved clinical measurements provided by the previous dosages of Cynomel. The equivalence of HSF to Cynomel in maintaining the measurements was calculated to be 1 capsule of HSF to 15 mcg of Cynomel. In this study, another subject stable on Cynomel switched to the dosage of HSF previously calculated to effectively maintain the clinical and physiological measurements. Methods: A single-subject two-phase repeated-measures study design was used. The subject was a 24-year-old female. She had been stable for a year and a half on 100 mcg of Cynomel. She underwent 12 comprehensive metabolic evaluations on different days in the Cynomel phase. She then immediately switched from Cynomel to HSF and underwent 12 additional evaluations. The evaluations included four basal measures: metabolic rate (BMR), heart rate (BHR), axillary temperature (BAT), and blood pressure (BBP). Other measures were body composition, mean hypothyroid symptoms intensity, Zungís depression scale, and pain distribution. Results: The subjectís physiological and clinical measurements, stable for 1.5 years on 100 mcg of Cynomel, were not statistically different when she used 7 capsules of HSF each day. The only significant differences in the subjectís measures were an increase in pain intensity and distribution during the HSF phase. Conclusion: For most measurements, including the BMR, BHR, and BAT, and hypothyroid symptoms intensity including depression, 7 capsules of HSF maintained the same values as 100 mcg of Cynomel. This outcome is consistent with that of the first study in which Cynomel and HSF were compared.

Keywords. Basal metabolic rate ● Basal temperature ● Cynomel ● Desiccated thyroid ● Hypo Support Formula ● RLC Labs ● Triiodothyronine

Citation: Lowe, J.C.: Comparative effects of Cynomel and Hypo Support Formula. Thyroid Science, 4(10):CR1-8, 2009.

Full Text Free in pdf format

Email:   Subscribe free to Thyroid Science

© 2009 Thyroid Science